Anthony C. Vitale

The Health Law Offices of Anthony C. Vitale
Law Center at Brickell Bay
2333 Brickell Avenue, Suite A-1
Miami, FL 33129
Tel: 305-358-4500
Fax: 305-358-5113

Communication Center

Phone: (305) 358-4500
(800) 299-4548
E-mail: avitale@vitalehealthlaw.com
Fax: (305) 358-5113
Web site: http://www.vitalehealthlaw.com

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Anthony C. Vitale is the President of the law firm bearing his name. The firm was established in 1982 and is recognized nationwide as a leader in health care law and consultation. The firm concentrates in criminal, civil, regulatory, administrative and licensure representation of health care providers, including physicians, other licensees, pharmacies, clinics, home health agencies, laboratories, durable medical equipment suppliers, CORF, CMHC/PHP, billing agents, wholesalers and other health care providers and suppliers.

Mr. Vitale has represented clients under investigation by the Department of Justice (FBI, DEA, FDA, IRS) the Office of the Inspector General (DHHS), Office of the Attorney General Statewide Prosecutor and Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, Florida Department of Insurance Division of Insurance Fraud and other investigatory bodies.

The firms representation also includes defense services to clients facing allegations of fraud and abuse, compliance counseling and the defense of civil, administrative, regulatory and criminal health care fraud, including internal/defense investigations; False Claims Act litigation; Settlement Negotiations; Withholding of Medicaid/Medicare Payments; Overpayments; Exclusion From Participation in Medicare/Medicaid Programs; Licensure and Certification; Anti-kickback violations; Medical Necessity Issues; Qui Tam Investigations (whistleblower), Prosecutions and Defense; Health Care Contracts, and physician self-referral (Stark).

PARTNERSHIP OF PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS

GERSTEIN, VITALE & STECKEL(1981 - 1985)
A law firm with emphasis on criminal defense, post conviction relief and appeals.

ASSISTANT STATE ATTORNEY
OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY, Miami-Dade County, Florida (1978 - 1981)Formerly, Chief Prosecutor with the Office of the State Attorney, Miami-Dade County.
       
1981-1982
Appointed by State Attorney Janet Reno Special Prosecutor, Office of the State Attorney, Miami-Dade County.

EDUCATION

Legal:
The Center for the Study of Law
Nova University
Ft. Lauderdale, Florida
J.D. 1977
Founding Editor of Law School Newspaper "The Perspective"

Undergraduate:
Pace University
New York, New York
Bachelor of Business Administration, 1974, Cum Laude

Peer review rated

Rated “AV” highest professional peer rating by Martindale-Hubbell

BAR ADMISSIONS/LICENSURE

The Florida Bar, 1978
United States Supreme Court
United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida
United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

TEACHING POSITIONS

Adjunct Professor, St. Thomas University, Miami, Florida, Master's Program Health Care Law.  2000- present

PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES AND ASSOCIATIONS

Member the Florida Bar
Member the American Bar Association (ABA)
ABA Subcommittee for Medicare and Medicaid Fraud and Abuse
ABA Health Law Section
ABA White Collar Crime Committee
Member Florida Academy of Health Care attorneys
Member Agency for Health Care Administration Workgroup on Fraud and Abuse Member American Health Lawyers Association
Member National Health Lawyers Association
Member the American Compliance Institute        
Member National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
Member Florida Academy of Healthcare Attorneys
Member Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

NOTABLE CASES – FLORIDA STATUTES DECLARED UNCONSTITUTIONAL

Florida Statute 817.505, Patient brokering declared unconstitutional: State of Florida vs. Sonia Bonilla Guzman, DDS, Ana Maria Bonilla Mendez, DDS, and John Anthony Rubio, Case No. 48-2003-CF-13501-O (9th Jud. Cir. February 1, 2005). Argued by Anthony C. Vitale and Richard Strafer on October 29, 2004.

Florida Statute 409.920, Medicaid Provider Fraud  Statute declared unconstitutional: State of Florida v. Gabriel Harden, et al., Case No. F00-38785 (11th Jud. Cir. February 5, 2003) and State of Florida v. Gabriel Harden, Case No. 3D03-521 (Fla. 3rd DCA Jan. 28, 2004), 2004 Fla. App. LEXIS 623, 29 Fla. L. Weekly D 593. Argued by Anthony C. Vitale and Richard Strafer on January 28, 2003.

On May 18, 2006, the Supreme Court of Florida affirmed the Third District Court of Appeal decision in State v. Harden, 873 So. 2d 352 (Fla. 3d DCA 2004) declaring unconstitutional the Anti-kickback section of the Florida Medicaid Provider Fraud Statute, 409.920(e).  The Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of all charges against all defendants in the case of State of Florida vs. Gabriel R. Harden, (Case No. S00-38785) as well as 3 dentists -Edward Polsky, D.D.S., Maria Rodriguez, D.D.S., Elsa Cottoreal, D.D.S., and others.

On April 23rd 2007, the United States Supreme Court denied certiorari and the decision of the Florida Supreme Court became final. 

PUBLICATIONS

Author – Anthony C. Vitale, the Florida Healthcare Law Compendium

Author - Anthony C. Vitale, the Florida Medical Center Legal Compliance Guide
        
Author - Anthony C. Vitale, Compliance Guide - Non Physician Owned Medical Clinics.

Author - Anthony C. Vitale, State Enforcement and Medicaid Fraud, American Bar Association, continuing Legal Education Course Materials, Healthcare Fraud - 2001.

Author - Anthony C. Vitale, Insurers Begin Denying Claims for Non-Registered Clinics, Florida Medical Business Journal, February, 2002.

Author - Anthony C. Vitale, New Board Rule Prohibits Docs From Practicing at Non-Physician Owned Clinics, Florida Medical Business Journal, April 6, 2001.

Co-Author with William Gompers, Florida Toughens, Broadens Law on Medicaid Fraud and Abuse. Medical Business South Florida Edition

Author - Anthony C. Vitale, P.A. Provider Alerts published monthly and provided to the health care community.  Provider Alerts identify current trends in health care, as well as changes in laws, rules and codes. Representative titles include:

Providers Question Fairness of Medicare Hearing System, June, 1997
        
Medicaid Targets Pediatric Providers for Overpayments, January, 1998
False Homebound Certification by Physicians Invoke Civil Money Penalty, April, 1997

Feds Investigating Billing Agent Contractors, August, 1997

Home Health Compliance Review Essential in Preparing for a Joint Task Force Audit, May, 1997

Federal and State Investigators Target Medical labs, August, 1997

Leased Employees May Now Perform Incident-To Services, February, 1997

Payments to DME's from Pharmacies under Marketing Arrangements Can Violate Anti-kickback Statutes, January, 1997

New Medicaid Statute Bans All Patient Brokering, August, 1996

Board of Medicine Declares Mere Allegation of Fraud as Basis for Emergency Suspension of Physician's License, January, 1996

Physician Assistant False Claims Advisory, August, 1995

SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS

Presenter - American Bar Association 16th Annual National Institute on Health Care Fraud 2006, Fort Lauderdale, May 3-5, 2006," Recent Developments for Challenging Health Care Fraud Statutes”

Speaker - Florida Bar Annual Meeting 2006 – Challenging State Allegations of Patient Brokering and Fee Splitting , Boca Raton, Florida

Presenter - American Bar Association 11th Annual National Institute on Health Care Fraud 2001, Miami, May 3-5, 2001, Workshop "State Enforcement and Medicaid Fraud."

Speaker - "Affirmative Civil Litigation - Defense of Federal Civil False Claims Actions" - U.S. Department of Justice Office of Legal Education, June 1994, Clearwater, Florida.

VIDEO/AUDIO PROGRAMS

Panel Member - WLRN T.V. Channel 36 - "You Be the Judge" September 17, 1998, Produced by the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.  Program regarding Medicare and Medicaid Fraud.

Anthony C. Vitale is widely quoted on health law matters in leading publications including the Wall Street Journal, Miami Herald, Tampa Tribune, Florida Daily Business Review, St. Petersburg Times, and U.S. News and World Report.

Health Law & Consulting Practice